February 4, 2025

Writing Women Out of the Footnotes

Allegra Goodman, author of our February ’25 Reese’s Book Club Pick shares the true story that inspired her novel, Isola.

Writing Women Out of the Footnotes

Allegra Goodman, author of our February '25 Reese's Book Club Pick shares the true story that inspired her novel, Isola.

Twenty-two years ago, on a family vacation to Montreal, I was sitting up in bed nursing my newborn daughter.  At six weeks, she woke up a lot, and so I nursed her while reading a stack of library books I had brought along for my sons.  In a children’s book about the explorer Jacques Cartier, I read a passage that stopped me short. It went something like this: In 1542, a French nobleman named Jean-François Roberval sailed to meet with Cartier in the territory that is now called Canada.  Roberval brought along his young ward, Marguerite de la Rocque, who annoyed him by having an affair aboard the ship. In his frustration, Roberval marooned Marguerite and her lover on a deserted island where she managed to survive for more than two years while fighting off polar bears.

Startled, I stared at the page. Wait.  What?  Who was this woman? Where did she find the strength? What happened to her?

The author said no more on the subject—but I could not stop thinking about the young woman marooned.  How did she end up on that ship? And how did she survive?  I grew up on an island, and I’ve always been drawn to novels such as Robinson Crusoe and Kidnapped.  What would it be like to write a novel about a woman cast away?  I dreamed of writing this story, but didn’t do it.  I wrote several other books, but I kept thinking about Marguerite.

Finally, when I was writing my latest novel Sam, a contemporary story about a girl who loved to boulder, Marguerite’s story started to open up  for me. Sam was a climber, a striver, a survivor and I began to  see Marguerite through that lens. Marguerite compelled me—but how would I approach her?

Like an actor, I searched for my character, trying to understand her from the inside.   I began to think that she should tell her own story in my novel—but how would I find her voice?

In the mornings, I worked on Sam and in the afternoons, I wrote by hand in a notebook, experimenting with different openings for the book that would become Isola.

Over and over, I tried to write the first line—and then one day, Marguerite spoke to me. 

I never knew my mother. She died the night that I was born, and so we passed each other in the dark . . .

From there, I knew Marguerite would tell me the rest.  I could hear her voice, and I knew she would guide me on her journey from France to the New World, from comfort, to adventure, from youthful arrogance to experience.

Emily Dickinson wrote, “There is no frigate like a book.”  I felt the truth in this as I set sail with Marguerite.  I hope you feel it when you read Isola.

Bon Voyage,

Allegra

Kicking off the week on a high note by finishing Once Upon A Time In Dollywood and getting ready to hear from @AshleyJordanWrites on the latest episode of Bookmarked, the Reese’s Book Club podcast. 🎧📖

New episode drops tomorrow — and trust us, you won’t want to miss this one. Expect all the feels: romance, stepping out of your comfort zone, and the journey of writing a debut novel. We're calendaring it in! 

Listen tomorrow on the @iHeartPodcast app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you love to listen!
"I hope you will also find that there is reassurance, maybe even a promise, whether you’re coming of age or not: that your anger is righteous and just. That the endurance with which you face the world is admirable. That your vulnerability, your longing to be wanted just as you are, is worthy." — @afarolfollmuth

To girls and women everywhere, we see you. 💙
Welcome to the club, Once Upon a Time in Dollywood. 💙

📷: @therealbookhustler
"You are important and you are powerful. Just as you are, in yourself, standing alone. Don’t let anyone, and especially no man, treat you as anything less."

We're still hung up on this iconic line from Stuck Up and Stupid. A fantastic reminder that you are worthy and certainly not stupid. 🩷
This weekend’s mood: resting, recharging, and rendezvousing with every iconic and authentic version of Cate Kay. 🧖‍♀️✨
This book gives us all the fireflies (iykyk) ✨ It's just so easy to ship Eve and Jamie in Once Upon A Time in Dollywood. We’re always here for the sunshine-and-stormcloud duo that just make each other better 🌤️💙
#ad This is your sign to slow your scroll ✨

Reese’s Book Club and Gevalia have partnered to help you slow down and find your calm with the perfect tools: delicious coffee and a good book. It’s time to reclaim a moment of joy. Give yourself permission to pause and head to our link in bio to shop Gevalia coffee.
✨ HOLD DOWN ✨ on this video for all the romance vibes and prepare to swoon!

And if you fell in love with the couples in Seven Days in June, Honey & Spice, or any of these titles, we promise you'll be obsessed with Eve and Jamie in Once Upon A Time In Dollywood. 💙
Enemies-to-lovers fans unite and add Honey & Spice to your TBR! ❤️‍🔥 Why is this trope truly the best? Sound off below!

📷: @chris.reads.a.lot
This post is dedicated to the special people who try to find beauty in everything. 💌

Recognize that iconic voice narrating Great Big Beautiful Life by @EmilyHenryWrites? It's the irreplaceable @JustJuliaWhelan — and she recently spilled all things audiobook on Bookmarked, the Reese's Book Club podcast, with @DanielleRobay.

Listen to the story behind the voice on @iHeartPodcast, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you love to listen.